A Visual Introduction to Boycott Outspan Action and the Blood-Citrus Topos

17 Oct

Over the last two years I have been researching the work of the radical anti-apartheid and anti-racist organization, Boycot Outspan Actie (Boycott Outspan Action). Founded in 1972 in Leiden, Holland, the BOA were led by the charismatic South African exile, Esau du Plessis.  After first contacting du Plessis in 2010, I have interviewed many key BOA activists and associates in Sweden and Holland; during this time I have been fortunate enough to have access to a range of compelling sources stored in private archives and correspondence. Much of this research will be published in my thesis in 2013. Here, as a little taster, I would like to provide you with a visual introduction to the organization that reworked the blood-sugar topos into a powerful anti-apartheid weapon.

The author in conversation with the former leader of the BOA, Esau du Plessis, at his home in Sweden

 

Despite their relatively small size in comparison to other Dutch anti-apartheid organizations of the era (with only two full time paid employees and between ten and twelve volunteers), I believe that the BOA were one of the most influential anti-apartheid and anti-racist organizations in Europe during the 1970s. Until now, little has been written on the BOA in either Dutch or English, “save a small and largely inaccurate entry by Sietse Bosgra” (du Plessis, 2012) in the SADET publication on the global anti-apartheid movement, and a chapter that  dedicates a few pages to the BOA in the Geographies of Commodity Chains (2004), by the geographers Charles Mather and Petrina Rowcroft. Mather and Carla Mackenzie write about the BOA’s ‘Inspan Girls’ in a paper on the Outspan Girls marketing campaigns, but they attribute the campaign to the wider Dutch anti-apartheid movement rather than the BOA. There are interesting reasons for the lack of coverage on the BOA that I address in my thesis. In time, I believe this will change – the BOA was remarkable for its success as a boycotting organization, unique in the Netherlands for its ‘whole world’ approach to racism and apartheid, and publicly compelling for its innovative culture jamming campaigns and media work.

BOA activists Rita Isaacs-Jonathan (left) and Esau du Plessis (right) at a BOA event (1977). The week long anti-apartheid action became a prototype for over fifty BOA urban campaigns carried out in the Netherlands between 1979 and 1989. Image courtesy of Esau du Plessis (2012)

BOA campaigns in the 1970s and 80s were based on the worldview that totally rejects racism as described by the Dutch scholar Karel Roskam (he  later became an enthusiastic supporter of the BOA) who in 1960 published the seminal work, Apartheid and Discrimination.

Click on image for link to Martin Leggasick’s chapter on ‘British Hegemony and the Origins of Segregation’ (1995). Leggasick positions Roskam’s thesis as a major influence on the historiography of racial segregation in South Africa.

Karel Roskam. Radio presenter and anti-apartheid theorist. Please click on image for a short biography.

Across their three major public projects (the boycott of Outspan citrus, the anti-emigration campaign, and the urban town campaigns) the BOA left their distinctive mark. To the chagrin of some development groups and a few other Dutch anti-apartheid organizations, the organization refused to separate apartheid in South Africa from everyday structures of racism in the Netherlands. To the BOA, apartheid was a logical, if wholly lamentable, extension of European racism. And evidence of European racism could be found in the attitudes and beliefs of many Dutch people. This implicating ideology was interpreted by some as too radical, the BOA’s open criticisms of the Den Uyl administration for its social and economic links with South Africa led other anti-apartheid activists to weakly accuse the BOA of duplicity (they were partly funded by a government grant).

In 1972-73 the BOA unleashed the blood-citrus topos on the Dutch public. Through the publication of one highly controversial image, the BOA awakened the power of anthropophagic suggestion and contaminated the idea of eating and drinking citrus from apartheid South Africa. The cartoon below, by BOA graphic designer Rob van der Aa, is arguably the most effective food boycotting image of recent European history. Its success can be measured threefold: by the complete withdrawal of Outspan oranges and grapefruit from the Dutch market  (previously the fourth largest captive market for Outspan citrus in Europe); by the image’s many imitations across other anti-apartheid movements; and by the legal banning of the image’s reproduction in Holland from 1973-5. The legal contest over the BOA’s central motif was framed in the national press as a debate over the freedom of expression in Holland. The publicity yielded huge boycott potential; the main Dutch supermarkets (Albert Heijn, The Spar, De Gruyter, Vroom en Dreesmaan) buckled to BOA demands days after they were threatened with wholesale boycotts of their stores.

 Unleashing the power of  the  squeezing trope: ‘Don’t Squeeze A South African Dry’

“Don’t Squeeze a South African Dry”

Van der Aa transplanted the black head on the image from a photograph of a boy playing among other children in a school playground, and placed it in the front-line of the anti-apartheid campaign. From here, what was truthfully an expression of joy, became an avatar for subjective and excruciating pain administered by the collared (and objectified) hand of ‘APARTHEID’. But the hand does what many hands do when making fresh orange juice; the image mobilises an individualised face of suffering at the hand of a universalised process for making juice from an orange. The image gives life to emotive interventions in corporeal interactions with oranges. In his discussion of offensive images, Mitchell (2005) attributes sentience, expression and transparency among their repertoire of power:

“Whatever is done to the image is somehow done to what it stands for…Indeed images are sometimes treated as pseudopersons – not merely as sentient creatures that can feel pain and pleasure but as responsible and responsive human beings. Images of this sort seem to look back at us, to speak to us, even be capable of suffering harm or of magically transmitting harm when violence is done to them” (Mitchell, 2005: 127).

The squeezing image was an accusation of European complicity in apartheid through the purchasing and consumption of Outspan citrus. Oranges were effective tools for the BOA to induce gut feelings of guilt and complicity. The material properties of the orange (with its fleshy water drenched interior and hard exterior prone to rapid dehydration once separated from the flesh), made it an obvious contender to mimic the environmental conditioning of human bodies.  The husk provided a metonym for drought or thirst and a metaphor for bone, and orange segments provided a metonym for quenching and metaphors for human flesh and blood. What is more, the essential quotidian violence (Probyn, 2000) required to eat or drink an orange (squeezing, dissecting, peeling, segmenting, sucking, grating) was adroitly applied by the BOA to the social and spatial squeezing of the labourer and the famine victim, and the dissection and segmentation of the entire non-white South African population. The apartheid orange belonged to a “harvest of shame” (BOA, 1973).

The image and it’s incumbent meaning received support from black South Africans. At the BOA Congress of 1973, James Phillips an exiled SACTU (South African Underground Trade Union) representative, spoke in defense of the BOA poster:

“First of all a note regarding the poster of the Boycott Outspan Action. I have heard many reactions to the poster. Some have said that it’s a bit too cruel, others that it was exactly the way it should be. When I look at this image of the hand on the head of what appears to be a child, I think that this hand is not doing what it should be doing. He should squeeze a bit harder, because that is in fact what I think is happening in South Africa. And I believe that the hand itself should show how tense the muscles are as they squeeze the life out of our people” (James Phillips. Translation, BOA Dokumentatiemap 2, 1973: 15).

The BOA’s work was innovative, provocative and meticulously planned. At the height of the Outspan citrus boycott they engaged a huge public with over 70% of Dutch people aware of their actions. They aimed at incorporating the ‘lowest threshold’ (a term that they used to encompass the Dutch white working class and the apartheid labourer) in their actions.

The multinational BOA ‘Inspan Girls’ with Ruth First, 1973.

Click over image for information on the CAO. In the summer of 1974 du Plessis made frequent trips from Leiden to Paris and founded the French version of the BOA, the CAO (Campaigne Anti-Outspan) with a Frenchman, Bernard Taillefer, who had read a French translation of the 1973 BOA Bulletin. Through utilising the BOA’s motif and slogan, and transferring its action models, the CAO became France’s first anti-apartheid organization.

With graphic designers, lawyers, and exiled poets among their number, the BOA could draw on plenty of creative inspiration. Their professional lawyer, Willem Van Manen, was also a talented caricaturist who helped develop the BOA’s image into the 1980s.

The Reclame Code Commissie (RCC), an advertising standards board launched an injunction against the BOA poster due to its supposed indecency, and for two years the squeezing image was officially banned from publication. This gave the image, and the BOA, a subversive edge, and drew sympathetic publicity from the liberal press. Van Manen (1975) suggests that the RCC were doing the dirty work for the South African president, Hans Botha.

‘Constructive Engagement’. Van Manen 1988. Courtesy of du Plessis.

Van Manen (1988). Courtesy of du Plessis.

Advertisements

4 Responses to “A Visual Introduction to Boycott Outspan Action and the Blood-Citrus Topos”

  1. hughcrosfield October 17, 2012 at 9:48 pm #

    Reblogged this on Landscape Surgery.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Review of Michael Carolan’s Embodied Food Politics « Chomping at the Bloodied Bit - January 24, 2013

    […] Next up will be a series of posts on the antiracist campaigns of Boycott Outspan Action following their boycott of Outspan citrus.  […]

  2. Margaret Thatcher and ‘Constructive Engagement’: Buying into Apartheid | Chomping at the Bloodied Bit - April 22, 2013

    […] the blog, you’ll probably guess that the anti-apartheid and antiracist organization, Boycott Outspan Action, will figure somehow. But for now I’d like to introduce the series with a discussion on what […]

  3. Rhodesia and Apartheid South Africa in the Far Right Popular Imagination | Hatful of History - June 19, 2015

    […] 1950s, anti-apartheid movements began in several Western countries (such as the UK, the USA and the Netherlands), highlighting the racism of the apartheid system in South Africa, as well as its neighbouring […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Jennifer McLaren

Exploring the past — stories and lives

object archives

reading and writing eccentric histories

Turbulent London

The historical geography of protests, riots and general mischief in London.

thetraffickingresearchproject.wordpress.com/

A contribution to the global dialogue on human trafficking

reps

'Race', Ethnicity & Post-Colonial Studies: an interdisciplinary network

Conflict & Security

Our thoughts on Conflict & Security and anything else of interest in the field of International Relations.

Race. Migration. Citizenship.

Postcolonial and Decolonial Perspectives

cultivating alternatives

Research and writing on alternatives to the dominant order.

Dr Red Chidgey

Feminist Media, Memory, Activism

Experimental Geographies

"There is tenderness only in the coarsest demand: that no-one shall go hungry any more" - Theodor Adorno, Minima Moralia (1974: 156)

Le Clic

Un blog dédié aux blogs et autres médias sociaux.

New Seeds

a reading notes blog in rhetoric/composition and postcolonial feminist/antiracist theory

Andy Davies's Blog

A WordPress.com site

The Orient Views

The Indigenous views of the eastern world

Dr Alun Withey

Welcome to my blog! I am an academic historian of medicine and the body, and 2014 AHRC/BBC 'New Generation Thinker'. Please enjoy and let me know what you think.

technophilia

researching philosophy and technology at the University of the West of England

This Sociological Life

A blog by sociologist Deborah Lupton

%d bloggers like this: